Skip to main content

Table 1 Baseline characteristics for the total sample, the PD-Lo patient group and PD-Hi patient group

From: The influence of depressive symptoms on the effectiveness of a short-term group form of Schema Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for personality disorders: a naturalistic study

Variable

Total sample (n = 225)

PD-Lo (n = 131)

PD-Hi (n = 94)

Test statistic (df)

p

Demographics

 Age n (mean)

 

225 (39.4)

131 (39.6)

94 (39.0)

F (1)= 0.229

.63

 Gender n (%)

male

82 (36)

51 (39)

31 (33)

χ2(1) = .837

.36

Cultural background n (%)

Dutch

156 (69)

96 (73)

60 (64)

χ2(2) = 5.279

.07

North-Western countries

19 (8)

15 (12)

8 (9)

  

Non-Western

46 (20)

20 (15)

26 (28)

  

 Marital status n (%)

single

157 (70)

91 (70)

66 (70)

χ2(2) = .259

.88

 

married/living together

46 (20)

28 (21)

18 (19)

  

divorced

22 (10)

12 (9)

10 (11)

  

 Living situation n (%)

Living alone

152 (68)

88 (67)

64 (68)

χ2(4) = 2.231

.69

Living alone with children

21 (9)

12 (9)

9 (10)

  

Living with parent/guardian

7 (3)

4 (3)

3 (3)

  

Living together

32 (14)

17 (13)

15 (16)

  

Living together with children

13 (6)

10 (8)

3 (3)

  

 Job status n (%)

Job

100 (44)

67 (51)

33 (35)

χ2(4) = 8.441

.08

Student

25 (11)

12 (9)

13 (14)

  

Sickness benefits/Social security benefits

44 (20)

24 (18)

20 (21)

  

unemployed

48 (21)

22 (17)

26 (28)

  

Other

7 (4)

6 (5)

2 (2)

  

 Educational level n (%)

Low

106 (48)

64 (51)

42 (45)

χ2(2) = 0.718

.70

Intermediate

72 (33)

40 (32)

32 (34)

  

High

41 (19)

22 (18)

19 (20)

  

Clinical characteristics

 Symptom severity, SCL-GSI Mean (SD)

 

210.72 (58.05)

176.60 (36.56)

258.26 (48.20)

F [1] = 208.73

.00**

 Schema severity, YSQ total Mean (SD)

 

2.95 (0.70)

2.64 (0.60)

3.39 (0.60)

F (1) = 86.168

.00**

Number personality disorders n (%)

 

one personality disorder

140 (62)

89 (68)

51 (54)

χ2(3) = 7.052

.13

 

two personality disorders

33 (15)

18 (14)

15 (16)

  
 

three personality disorders

51 (23)

24 (18)

27 (29)

  
 

four personality disorders

12 (5)

4 (3)

8 (9)

  

Specific personality disorder n (%)

 

borderline personality disorder

49 (22)

28 (21)

21 (22)

χ2(3) = 5.462

.70

 

avoidant personality disorder

33 (15)

22 (17)

11 (12)

  
 

personality disorder not otherwise specified

126 (56)

71 (54)

55 (58)

  
 

other personality disorder

17 (7)

10 (8)

7 (8)

  

Medication n(%)

 

109 (48)

55 (42)

54 (57)

χ2(1) = 5.239

.02*

Type of medication n(%)

antidepressants

75 (53)

37 (56)

38 (51)

χ2(3) = .561

.91

antipsychotics

22 (16)

9 (14)

13 (17)

  

benzodiazepines

27 (19)

12 (18)

15 (20)

  

other mental

17 (12)

8 (12)

9 (12)

  

Medication somatics n(%)

 

6 (5)

    

Prior treatment for current treatment n(%)

 

202 (91)

113 (87)

89 (96)

χ2(1) = 4.895

.03*

Drop-out history n(%)

 

59 (28)

30 (24))

29 (33)

χ2(1) = 2.170

.14

  1. PD-Lo Personality Disorder with low severity of depressive symptoms; PD-Hi Personality Disorder with high severity of depressive symptoms; North-Western countries (North-Western Europe, North-America, Australia) * p < .05, **p < .01