Skip to main content

Table 2 Topics and number of statements issued by each CPG

From: Characteristics and quality of clinical practice guidelines for depression in adults: a scoping review

Theme

CANMAT

WHO

NICE

GuiaSalud

ACP

APA

RANZCP

USTF

VADoD

Korea

BAP

Screening

1 R

 

1 R

4R 1 GCP

   

1 R

1 R

 

3 R 1 GCP

Diagnosis

1 R

 

4 R

1 GCP

    

1 R

 

1 R 3 GCP

Pharmacological treatment

 Pharmacological treatment: general

43 R

 

35 Rb

8 R 5 GCP

1 Ra

60 Rc

5 R 9 CBRa

 

6 R

 

115 R 15 GCP

 Pharmacological treatment: 1st line

1 R

  

3 R

 

6 R

3 R

 

1 R

 

7 R

 Pharmacological treatment: 2nd line

1 R

  

2 R

 

3 R

1 R

   

7 R

Psychological treatment

 Psychological treatment: general

6 R

 

7 Rb

2 R 1 GCP

1 Ra

21 Rc

3 R 3 CBRa

 

5 R

 

7 R 3 GCP

 Psychological treatment: recommends at least one specific therapy

14R

 

15 Rb

4 R

 

9 R

3 R

 

6 R

5 R

15 R

Other non-pharmacological treatments

 Electro-stimulation

9 R

 

11 R

4 R 2 GCP

 

16 R

7 R 2 CBR

 

5 R

 

20 R 6 GCP

 Acupuncture

1 R

12 R

         

 St. John’s wort

1 R

 

1R

1 R 1 GCP

 

3 R

  

1 R

 

2 R

 Light therapy

1 R

    

1 R

  

1 R

 

6 R

 Exercise

1 R

 

1 R

2 R

    

1 R

1 R

3 R

 Yoga

1 R

          

 Sleep deprivation

1 R

          

 Others treatments

10 R

    

3 R

    

4 R

Other statements

18 R

 

35 R

13 R 3 GCP

 

89 R

3 R 8 CBR

 

6 R

1 R

9 R 22 GCP

Total of statements

110 R

12 R

108 R

43 R 14 GCP

1 Ra

211 Rc

25 R 32 CBR

1 R

31 R

7 R

199 R 50 GCP

  1. R: recommendations, GCP: good clinical practice, CBR: consensus-based recommendation
  2. a 01 recommendation included both pharmacological and psychological themes
  3. b 02 recommendations included both pharmacological and psychological themes
  4. c 06 recommendations included both pharmacological and psychological themes