Skip to main content

Table 2 Inter-rater reliability using intra-class correlations (ICC) all as compared with the expert witness at time of trial

From: Moral cognition, the missing link between psychotic symptoms and acts of violence: a cross-sectional national forensic cohort study

 

Expert witness (n = 55)

Admitting or treating clinician (n = 50)

Patient self-rating (n = 51)

Independent research clinician (n = 55)

Average ICC

 

n

%

ICC

n

%

ICC

n

%

ICC

n

%

 

Care-harm

11

20.0

.59

9

17.6

.58

20

39.2

.77

11

20.0

.80

Fairness-injustice

35

63.6

.95

34

66.7

.51

24

47.1

.64

36

65.0

.79

Loyalty-betrayal

30

54.5

.75

23

45.1

.42

23

45.1

.71

29

52.0

.75

Authority

17

30.9

.73

13

25.5

.75

18

35.3

.83

17

30.9

.89

Purity-disgust

14

25.5

.69

15

29.4

.52

10

19.6

.40

4

7.3

.64

Average

  

.74

  

.56

  

.67

  

.77