Skip to main content

Table 8 What were the barriers to change at baseline, according to staff perceptions?

From: The side effects of service changes: exploring the longitudinal impact of participation in a randomised controlled trial (DOORWAYS) on staff perceptions of barriers to change

Item number (N=)

Type of item

Total “disagree” responses (%)

Total “agree” responses (%)

1 (N = 124) When it comes to change, information is not circulated effectively on my ward.

BARRIER

59 (48)

65 (52)

2 (N = 122) I feel confident when delivering new changes.

ENABLER

15 (12)

107 (88)

3 (N = 123) My whole team is regularly consulted about new ideas for ward practices.

ENABLER

20 (16)

103 (84)

4 (N = 124) I’m too busy to keep up to date with information about the changes that are happening on my ward.

BARRIER

84 (68)

40 (32)

5 (N = 123) We can easily fit new changes in with our usual ward practices.

ENABLER

88 (72)

35 (28)

6 (N = 124) I feel disheartened when others do not want to get involved in changes.

BARRIER

28 (23)

96 (77)

7 (N = 121) I think that managing risk is more important than delivering new changes.

BARRIER

43 (36)

78 (64)

8 (N = 124) Changes just increase my workload and make my life harder.

BARRIER

81 (65)

43 (35)

9 (N = 122) It is not clear how all changes that we are asked to make will really benefit my ward.

BARRIER

56 (46)

66 (54)

10 (N = 124) My teammates think that there is no point trying to implement some changes because they won’t work.

BARRIER

75 (60)

49 (40)

11 (N = 123) I find it de-motivating when new changes do not take patients’ wishes into account.

BARRIER

17 (14)

106 (86)

12 (N = 121) I think that some staff would rather let others take the lead in making changes.

BARRIER

26 (21)

95 (79)

13 (N = 120) When some staff stop engaging with planned changes resistance spreads through my whole team.

BARRIER

42 (35)

78 (65)

14 (N = 123) I do not really understand how to deliver some of the changes that are suggested by the management.

BARRIER

76 (62)

47 (38)

15 (N = 119) Changes are audited to increase their consistent delivery on my ward.

ENABLER

19 (16)

100 (84)

16 (N = 121) I always challenge team members who are avoiding delivering new changes.

ENABLER

43 (36)

78 (64)

17 (N = 123) Inadequate staffing prevents changes being successful on my ward.

BARRIER

13 (11)

110 (89)

18 (N = 123) Poor leadership prevents changes happening on my ward.

BARRIER

48 (39)

75 (61)

  1. Note: VOCALISE items were answered using a Likert scale (Strongly Agree = 1, Agree = 2, Slightly Agree = 3, Slightly Disagree = 4, Disagree = 5, Strongly Disagree = 6), however for simplicity answers are presented here in terms of positive/negative responses