Skip to main content

Table 7 Comparative psychometric properties of the SPHERE-21 and BDI

From: Validation and psychometric properties of the Somatic and Psychological HEalth REport (SPHERE) in a young Australian-based population sample using non-parametric item response theory

 

SPHERE-21

BDI

Number of items

14 (for anxiety-depression)

21

Short form for clinical use

SPHERE-12 (six items for anxiety-depression)

BDI-11

IRT requirements

Monotonicity verified

Good correlation of items with the latent trait

Monotonicity breached for items 9 and 10

Poor correlation of item 19 with the latent trait [53]

Sex DIF

Limited (DIF < 0.25)

Large DIF for item 14 (DIF = 0.32) Limited otherwise (DIF < 0.25) [53]

Age group DIF

Limited (DIF < 0.25); comparable construct from age 9 to 28 years

Not tested at item level (IRT)

Not investigated in a population sample

Comparable structure and internal consistency (Cronbach’s alpha) for adolescent inpatients [98]

Language(s)

Arabic, Cantonese, Croatian, Dutch, English, Greek, Italian, Japanese, Mandarin, Portuguese, Serbian, Spanish, Turkish, Vietnamesea

Arabic, Chinese, English, Farsi, Finnish, French, German, Japanese, Korean, Norwegian, Portuguese, Spanish, Swedish, Turkish

Test-retest

0.47 [0.23,0.66] at three months

0.48–0.86 [80] depending on the sample and test-retest interval

Cronbach’s alpha

0.87

0.81 [80, 81]

Heritability

0.41 [0.32,0.49] between ages nine and 12 years, 0.42 [0.33,0.50] at 13 to 14 years, 0.29 [0.20,0.38] at 15 to 16 years and 0.37 [0.21,0.51] between ages 17 and 28 years

(AE models, anxiety-depression scores)

0.18 [0.05,0.31]

(AE model, mean age 31 years, range 16–71) [84]

Association with DSM-IV diagnoses

Significant from age 15 years with alcohol and Marijuana dependence; and from age 13 years for MDD and social anxiety (anxiety-depression subscale).

Not evaluated in general population

Price

Free

Around 2 USD per questionnaire [99]

  1. aQuestionnaires in non-English languages available on demand. Please contact Pr. Ian Hickie (ian.hickie@sydney.edu.au)
  2. Here, we used the BDI questionnaire as gold standard as it is one of the oldest, most used and most tested depression questionnaire. For other widely used questionnaires such as the Achenbach or Hamilton rating scales, some the methods used here (e.g. NIRT modelling, twin models) have never been applied, which makes the comparison less meaningful