Skip to main content

Table 3 Results of Cochran's Q and Mcnenar's Testing for questions about participants attitudes towards people who have a mental health problem or disorder.

From: Working Together for Mental Health: Evaluation of a one-day mental health course for human service providers

 

% of desired responses

Cochran's Q

McNemar's Test (α = 0.05)

 

Pre

Post

Follow-up

Significance (α = 0.05)

Pre – Post p value

Post – Follow-up p value

Pre – Follow-up p value

Questions that the course is designed to promote agreement or strong agreement with.

1

Mental illness can happen to anybody

 

99

97

99

0.165

-

-

-

10

As far as possible, mental health services should be provided through community based facilities

 

74

80

74

0.191

-

-

-

13

People with schizophrenia can work in regular jobs

 

81

91

86

0.003

0.004

0.1430

.077

14

I could be friends with someone who has had schizophrenia

 

94

97

97

0.174

-

-

-

Questions that the course is designed to promote disagreement or strong disagreement with.

2

People who have a mental illness are more likely than other people to be dangerous

 

70

88

71

0.000

<0.001

<0.001

0.860

3

There is something about people with mental illness that makes it easy to tell them from normal people

 

82

85

84

0.710

-

-

-

4

Once a person has a mental illness they are always unwell

 

90

94

91

0.228

-

-

-

5

People who have had mental illness are never going to contribute much to society

 

97

98

97

0.641

-

-

-

6

Someone with a mental illness is more likely than other people to have poor personal hygiene

 

85

82

85

0.625

-

-

-

7

If I got a mental illness I would feel I was to blame

 

78

79

78

0.947

-

-

-

8

It is frightening to think of people with mental illness living in residential neighbourhoods

 

91

94

94

0.390

-

-

-

9

I would not want to live next door to someone who has been mentally ill

 

95

92

93

0.549

-

-

-

11

As soon as a person shows signs of a mental illness, he/she should be hospitalised

 

93

95

91

0.157

-

-

-

12

I would feel uncomfortable talking to someone with a mental illness

 

93

91

93

0.676

-

-

-

15

I would not want to have a colleague who had schizophrenia

 

88

88

93

0.102

-

-

-

16

I would not want any of my children to get into a relationship with someone who had schizophrenia, even if the person had recovered

 

66

67

66

0.947

-

-

-