Skip to main content

Table 3 HCR-20 scores and discharge by tribunals - crude data and marginal means adjusted for the DUNDRUM-3 programme completion score and DUNDRUM-4 recovery score (omitting item D-4-R item 5 ′risk’ to avoid circularity)

From: Prospective study of factors influencing conditional discharge from a forensic hospital: the DUNDRUM-3 programme completion and DUNDRUM-4 recovery structured professional judgement instruments and risk

 

‘Raw’ data, means (S.D.)

Marginal means (S.E.) adjusted for DUNDRUM-3 score

Marginal means (S.E.) adjusted for DUNDRUM-4 score (omitting item 5 ‘risk’)

 

Not discharged

Discharged

ANOVA

Not discharged

Discharged

ANOVA

Not discharged

Discharged

ANOVA

HCR-20

N = 44

N = 12

F/p

N = 44

N = 12

F/p

N = 44

N = 12

F/p

Historical

12.5(3.9)

9.5(2.9)

5.8/0.019

11.7(0.4)

10.5(0.8)

1.4/0.2

11.8(0.4)

10.0(0.8)

3.3/0.074

Clinical

3.6(2.8)

1.0(1.2)

9.9/0.003

3.5(0.3)

3.4(0.6)

0.007/0.9

3.6(0.3)

3.1(0.6)

0.4/0.5

Risk

2.7(1.9)

0.5(0.5)

13.9/<0.001

2.5(0.3)

3.3(0.6)

1.2/0.3

2.5(0.3)

3.2(0.6)

1.3/0.3

Dynamic

6.2(4.3)

1.5(1.5)

13.5/0.001

6.0(0.5)

6.8(1.4)

0.3/0.6

6.1(0.5)

6.4(1.0)

0.7/0.8

Total

18.7(6.3)

11.0(3.8)

16.1/<0.001

17.1(0.6)

16.4(1.4)

0.2/0.7

17.2(0.6)

16.0(1.2)

0.8/0.4