Skip to main content

Table 2 Determinants of discharge: crude data and marginal means adjusted for HCR-20 total score

From: Prospective study of factors influencing conditional discharge from a forensic hospital: the DUNDRUM-3 programme completion and DUNDRUM-4 recovery structured professional judgement instruments and risk

 

Crude data, means (SD)

Marginal means (SE) adjusted for HCR-20 total scores

Not discharged

Discharged

ANOVA

Not discharged

Discharged

ANOVA

N = 44

N = 12

F/p

N = 44

N = 12

F/p

DUNDRUM-1 triage security

28.9(4.4)

27.4(3.2)

1.1/0.290

28.4(0.6)

29.0(1.2)

0.2/0.656

DUNDRUM-3 programme completion

13.9(6.7)

3.9(4.6)

14.6/0.001

13.7(0.7)

8.3(1.5)

10.1/0.002

DUNDRUM-4 recovery

13.8(6.1)

4.4(3.5)

15.3/0.001

13.3(0.7)

10.0(1.4)

6.6/0.013

DUNDRUM-4 omitting item 5 ‘risk’

11.7(4.7)

5.9(5.0)

9.2/0.004

11.6(0.6)

9.7(1.3)

1.8/0.2

GAF

49.7(15.0)

70.0(9.6)

11.9/0.001

49.6(1.6)

62.0(3.2)

3.9/0.051

PANSS

      

Positive

14.1(9.0)

7.5(1.7)

6.3/0.015

13.2(1.1)

11.1(2.2)

0.1/.9

Negative

17.7(10.0)

8.7(2.0)

9.7/0.003

16.8(1.2)

12.3(2.5)

0.6/0.5

General

31.6(12.9)

20.0(3.5)

9.3/0.004

30.2(1.6)

25.2(3.2)

0.6/0.5

Total

63.5(29.4)

36.2(6.5)

10.0/0.002

60.1(3.5)

48.6(7.1)

0.4/0.5

HCR-20

      

Historical

12.5(3.9)

9.5(2.9)

5.8/0.019

n/a

n/a

n/a

Clinical (current)

3.6(2.8)

1.0(1.2)

9.9/0.003

n/a

n/a

n/a

Risk (future)

2.7(1.9)

0.5(0.5)

13.9/<0.001

n/a

n/a

n/a

Dynamic (C + R)

6.2(4.3)

1.5(1.5)

13.5/0.001

n/a

n/a

n/a

Total

18.7(6.3)

11.0(3.8)

16.1/<0.001

n/a

n/a

n/a

S-RAMM

      

Background

9.4(2.8)

9.0(2.9)

0.2/0.667

9.2(0.4)

9.6(0.9)

0.09/0.759

Current

4.5(2.6)

2.33(1.5)

7.3/0.009

4.2(0.3)

3.4(0.7)

0.96/0.331

Future

5.2(2.6)

3.4(2.7)

4.2/0.044

4.9(0.4)

4.5(0.7)

0.18/0.672

Dynamic (C + F)

9.6(4.6)

5.8(3.7)

7.2/0.010

9.0(0.6)

7.9(1.2)

0.66/0.421

Total

19.0(5.3)

14.8(4.9)

6.23/0.16

18.3(0.7)

17.4(1.4)

0.26/0.612

SAPROF

23.3(6.1)

28.8(4.2)

8.52/0.005

24.3(0.7)

25.3(1.3)

0.4/0.515

START-S

27.84(8.7)

38.16(4.0)

15.7/<0.001

29.1(0.9)

33.2(1.8)

3.6/0.060

START-V

10.8(7.6)

1.8(3.1)

16.0/<0.001

9.7(0.8)

6.1(1.6)

3.9/0.054